As a freelance consultant, I enjoy the variety of working on different projects with diverse people & organisations.
I’ll encounter a great idea of way of working that I’ll take to the next client or project.
Conversely: I experience something that was unsuccessful & therefore avoid it next time. I’ve covered this in top 10 mistakes
I also see many commonalities across these projects & organisations. The topic of this post is one I’m calling it the BIM Rabbit Hole. I encounter this over & over again, so much it could be described as endemic within design & construction projects.
In essence: Everyone gets caught up doing BIM, but no-one can explain why
In other words, all you can see is dirt & all the other bunnies in the warren digging away, so you just keep going. You lose sight of where you are heading. BIM becomes a self-sustaining thing in its own right, rather than a means to an end.
Quite often, questioning “why?” leads to non-sequiturs & broken logic:
Q: Why are you doing BIM ?
A: Because it’s in the specification
Q: Why is it in the specification ?
A: Because our BIM consultant wrote the specification
Q: Why did you pay a consultant to write a specification ?
A: We thought we’d save money
Q: Are you saving money ?
A: We don’t know…
Incidentally, I see the same phenomenon across other branches of technology, so this post could be equally called the ‘the ‘AI Rabbit Hole’ or the ‘Analytics Rabbit Hole’ with just a few adjustments.
Red Flags
There is no definitive test of being in the BIM Rabbit Hole, but these indicators might be useful in examining your project or organisation. This is how I make my living, so get in touch if you need assistance.
π The question “why BIM ?” can’t be simply answered
π If the answer is “to produce drawings”, that is not a compelling reason alone
π BIM objectives and metrics are not defined
π Tangible BIM benefits can’t be identified
π BIM success stories consist of a 3D model graphic in a report or board paper, with a message of “we are doing clever stuff” but no substance behind it
π Normal people can’t understand your BIM documents
π Other than BIM experts, no-one has read these documents
π BIM gets bogged down in technical minutiae with no focus on business issues such as value or risk.
π You have a BIM team but are unsure what they do (other than BIM)
π Only the BIM team do BIM
Others (designers, engineers, managers, planners etc) don’t do BIM
π Tasks take longer than they used to for the same result
π Quality of outputs such as drawings has declined, often accompanied by an increase in data quantity (loads of data, little value)
π Digital Deliverables such as as-built models or asset data is are specified, but there is no capability or plan to use it beyond construction
π BIM is a box-ticking exercise, rather than being focussed on areas with highest business value
π BIM processes and outputs just get added, rather than replacing inefficient ones
π Meaningless BIM-based metrics such as “zero clashes” are used, but the design still sucks
Conclusion
In my post ROI of BIM I acknowledge the difficulty in quantifying the value of BIM- for example: what is the value of avoiding a fuck-up on site ? What is the value of a well-designed building that is efficient over a 50-year operating life ?
The challenge with BIM is often in bridging across technical and business-level people, with hurdles of communication and understanding:
- The BIM-boffins can’t communicate in clear & simple terms
- The MBA types don’t understand BIM technical constraints and issues
- Clients & management don’t understand it either- they see money going out the door for BIM but are not sure if it comes back in
If you have a feeling that you might be in the BIM Rabbit Hole, I’d suggest taking an honest & objective look at your project or organisation. The above red flags might be a good starting point.
I’m certainly not arguing that BIM cannot have a benefit, but it is critical to first define what you will do & why, and to progressively measure yourself against this, making adjustments as needed.

You must be logged in to post a comment.